The Crumple Zone · printable sheet

Correction authority map

Map who can correct a failure at each level, from the record to the institution's authority to decide at all, and see whether anyone with the power to order a change sits at the level the failure does.

Print this page from your browser. It fits one A4 or US Letter page and reads in black and white. Nothing you write on paper reaches this site.

Failure:

Institution:

Mapped by, and date:

Solid box, binding route. Someone who can order the correction at that level. Write the rule, statute, contract or order that gives them the power.

Dashed box, nominal route. Someone who can hear the failure, record it or recommend a change, and cannot order one.

The six levels, lowest first

A failure that repeats after a fix at one level points to a level above it.

  1. 1. The recordwhat is held about this person is wrong
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend
  2. 2. The decisionthe record was right and the decision made from it was wrong
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend
  3. 3. The rulethe decision followed the rule, and the rule is wrong for cases like this
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend
  4. 4. The burdenthe rule works only because someone else absorbs a cost it never counts
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend
  5. 5. The questionthe rule answers the wrong question, so a correct answer still fails the person
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend
  6. 6. The jurisdictionthe failures outlast every reform, so the institution should not be deciding this at all
    Binding: who can order the change, and the rule that says so
    Nominal: who can hear, record or recommend

Level the failure sits on:

Highest level with a binding route:

If the second is lower than the first, a correction can fix the case and keep the cause. Name who could close the gap, and the date you will ask them.