A Black grand-midwife in the rural South has delivered generations of children and seen their mothers through postpartum complications. Then the state passes a licensing law. The next time a family sends for her, going is a crime, and the physicians who campaigned for the law call her filthy, superstitious and dangerous.
Standard histories of American medicine present the buildup of capital in foundations, medical schools and hospitals as a story of scientific progress.
The narrative follows a familiar arc. In the beginning lay ignorance: unstandardized apprenticeship, folk remedies, and midwives practicing in frontier cabins. Then came enlightenment and philanthropy. Corporate foundations endowed university laboratories. The 1910 Flexner Report purged uncredentialed competition. Aseptic surgical suites replaced home births, and magnificent marble hospitals rose across American cities. In this telling, health is a technical commodity invented by researchers, standardized by professional associations, and purchased through insurance.
That story is persuasive because its achievements are real. Anesthesia, sterile surgery, antibiotics, and cardiovascular interventions transformed human life. What makes the official historiography dishonest is less what it celebrates than what it systematically erases to keep the narrative orderly.
Told from the hospital administrator’s point of view, this history does what the enclosure of common land once did. It takes millennia of communal, domestic, and mutual aid care practices and rewrites them as dangerous folklore, which justifies replacing them with a capital-intensive monopoly.
The Flexner enclosure
Modern American medicine took its definitive institutional shape in 1910, when the Flexner Report, commissioned by the Carnegie Foundation, came out.
Standard medical textbooks still revere Abraham Flexner’s survey as the dawn of scientific rigor. He visited all 155 medical schools in the United States and Canada and found lax admission standards, missing laboratory equipment, and proprietary colleges that ran as diploma mills. His recommendations set the modern pattern: two years of basic laboratory science followed by two years of clinical training inside university-affiliated hospitals.
The consequences of that reform were catastrophic.
By requiring massive capital (expensive laboratories, dedicated hospital beds, and full-time faculty), the Flexner standard put medical education out of reach for all but wealthy institutions. E. Richard Brown argued in Rockefeller Medicine Men that the foundations paying for the reform used their grants to shape medicine to the needs of capitalist society.1 In the quarter-century after the report, more than half of all American medical schools closed or merged. Among the casualties were five of the seven existing Black medical colleges in the country, along with most of the medical colleges that trained women and working-class students.
Flexner’s own text was explicit about its racial politics. Black doctors, Flexner wrote, would practice only among their own race; their schooling should stress “hygiene rather than surgery”; and the case for training them at all was self-protection: a Black American with hookworm or tuberculosis, the report said, “communicates them to his white neighbors.” The Flexner standard concentrated medical authority in the hands of affluent white men and entrenched structural disparities that persist a century later.
Criminalizing midwives and community caregivers
While foundation capital reshaped medical education from above, the American Medical Association waged a parallel war from below against community caregivers.
Throughout the nineteenth century, ordinary health (from childbirth and wound management to chronic elder care) sat firmly within the community. In the rural South, Black grand-midwives delivered generations of children, managed postpartum complications, and supported families through illness with deep botanical and physiological knowledge. In immigrant neighborhoods, mutual aid lodges pooled weekly dues to hire doctors on retainer and provide sickness benefits.
To the emerging medical establishment, these networks meant lost revenue. Physicians organized aggressive legislative campaigns to restrict midwifery, and labeled traditional healers filthy, superstitious, and dangerous. Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English read that campaign in Witches, Midwives, and Nurses as a political struggle of sex and class that the regular doctors won without better skills.2 States passed licensing laws that made traditional midwifery a crime. Meanwhile hospitals opened private obstetrics wards that turned a communal event into an expensive surgical procedure.
The enclosure of health turned care from a shared community capacity into an hourly professional transaction. When care became a market commodity, people without capital were priced out of survival, while the state dismantled the communal networks that had sustained them.
Medicine without politics
The central distortion of mainstream historiography is that it keeps separating health from political economy.
Standard accounts treat epidemic disease, maternal mortality, and life expectancy as biological variables governed by pathogens and pharmaceuticals. By isolating the body inside the exam room, medical history hides the social terrain that makes people sick in the first place. Enslaved people on plantations didn’t suffer poor health because they lacked board-certified physicians; they suffered because chattel slavery was an architecture of violent extraction. Black families living under Jim Crow didn’t face higher infant mortality because of genetic deficits; they faced it because municipal governments denied them clean water, paved roads, and hospital admission.
When healthcare history looks only at medical breakthroughs, it shields the medical industry from political criticism. It credits pharmaceutical companies and hospital networks with every increase in life expectancy. It ignores how much of the twentieth century’s gain in health came from outside the clinic: the eight-hour workday and workplace safety regulations that labor fought for, indoor plumbing, and universal sanitation. Thomas McKeown argued in The Role of Medicine that mortality in England and Wales fell mainly with rising standards of living rather than medical treatment.3
A truthful history of health can’t be written from the viewpoint of the executive suite or the laboratory bench. It has to be written from the bodies of the people who carried the burden: the families who nursed the sick through epidemics, the midwives who were outlawed to protect hospital balance sheets, and the communities that preserved life long before the state decided health was something you had to buy.
Notes
E. Richard Brown, Rockefeller Medicine Men: Medicine and Capitalism in America (University of California Press, 1979), ch. 4, “Reforming Medical Education: Who Will Rule Medicine?” Brown treated scientific medicine as a tool that the medical profession and the corporate class developed to serve their own needs, not as the natural result of progress in science, which is the argument this essay opens with.
Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English, Witches, Midwives, and Nurses: A History of Women Healers (Feminist Press, 1973). Their account also covers the Flexner closures and the fees midwives earned that doctors wanted for themselves, two points this essay repeats.
Thomas McKeown, The Role of Medicine: Dream, Mirage, or Nemesis? (Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, 1976). McKeown put most weight on better nutrition and gave public health measures little credit. Simon Szreter disputed that in “The Importance of Social Intervention in Britain’s Mortality Decline c.1850–1914: A Re-interpretation of the Role of Public Health,” Social History of Medicine 1, no. 1 (1988): 1–38, crediting preventive public health and local authorities’ response to urban crowding, which is nearer this essay’s list. Both wrote about Britain, not the United States.