On New Year’s Day 2021 Bhavin Shah, a physician from suburban Chicago, broke his arm skiing in Wisconsin. In the emergency room at Froedtert South in Pleasant Prairie he was examined, X-rayed, given pain relief and splinted, and the next day he had surgery at a hospital in the Chicago area. The emergency room’s bill included $6,961.75 under a code for treating a fracture of the upper arm bone without an incision, a treatment his records didn’t show. His share of the bill came to $3,319.05. When the couple appealed, the hospital declined to change the charges. When they complained to UnitedHealthcare, his insurer, it answered that the claim had been processed correctly.1
His wife, Sunita Kalsariya, found the line. She manages the billing at his medical practice. It took her months to get a bill that listed procedure codes, and the hospital would release his records only on a notarized form sent by mail. In November 2021 the bill went to a debt collector, and the hospital recalled it after she called. She complained to the Illinois attorney general. In May 2022 the couple appealed again, pointing to the mismatch between the charges and the records, and the hospital wrote back that the visit had been coded wrongly and should have been billed as a splint. A month later his balance was $1,214.91, about $2,100 less.2
UnitedHealthcare paid what the claim said, which is what an insurer is set up to do, and the error was the hospital’s. Getting it corrected took nearly a year and a half and a person whose job is reading codes against records, and this household happened to have one. Other households have to buy the skill.
Whole industries profit when paperwork stays hard. Billing advocates typically charge $100 or more an hour, and some work on contingency for 25 to 35 percent of what they save.3 A patient who hires an advocate pays twice, once in the hours spent before finding help and once in the fee. The cost of correcting the hospital’s error falls on the patient, and a small business has grown up in the space between.
A market made of mismatches
Benefits navigators help people through applications written for someone with a filing cabinet and a free Tuesday. Insurance-appeal specialists contest denials the insurer’s own reviewers could have caught. Credit-repair firms dispute entries the bureaus should never have recorded. Disability-claim representatives carry applicants through a process that rejects many of them at first and approves some of the same people on appeal.4 Tax preparers exist partly because tax law is complex and partly because filing is harder than the government’s own information would require. Inside companies, the escalation desk and the executive complaints team exist to fix, for the customers loud enough to reach them, what the front line wasn’t allowed to fix for everyone.
Call this the repair economy. Each part exists because an institution’s mismatch with the people it serves was pushed onto those people, and the pushing created demand. Where the people had money, the demand became a market. Where they didn’t, it became a charity, a legal aid clinic, a volunteer tax site, a nonprofit that answers the phone.
The size of the repair economy is a rough measure of how much burden has been transferred. Pamela Herd and Donald Moynihan showed that the learning, compliance and psychological costs of dealing with government are allocated by political choice, and that they ration access as effectively as any eligibility rule.5 The repair economy is where those costs go when people try to pay them down. Every paid hour of navigation is an hour of institutional work the institution declined to do, bought back from a third party at the individual’s expense. Identical coverage can come with twenty phone calls, and the repair economy is the industry that sells help with the dialing.
Revenue that depends on the error
Once repair is a business, it acquires interests. A credit-repair firm does better when credit reports are wrong. Billing advocates on contingency do better when bills are opaque, and tax-preparation companies do better when filing stays difficult. That takes no bad faith from anyone who works in these firms, only revenue that depends on the error continuing and pays for lobbying.
The best-documented American case is tax filing, traced in detail in Better Alternatives. The IRS already receives much of the information needed to prepare many simple returns, and other countries use that information to send citizens a pre-filled return to check.6 In the United States, commercial tax-preparation companies spent years lobbying against government-prepared or government-provided filing. For two decades the federal free-filing option ran through an industry arrangement that steered eligible filers toward paid products;7 when the agency finally built its own Direct File tool, the industry fought it until the program was scrapped after two seasons.8 The details are contested, but the shape is plain. A burden created a market, and the market worked to keep the burden.
Here the repair economy stops being a symptom and becomes a participant. An institution that shifts its error costs onto individuals can at least be embarrassed by the shift. A firm that earns its living from the shift has every reason to call it natural, and a trade association to say so.
Why independent advocates are often indispensable
Independent advocates are often indispensable, precisely because institutions have incentives to hide their own mistakes. An insurer that denies a claim also decides whether the denial was wrong. Hospitals that miscode a bill control the itemized statement. A benefits agency that loses a document is also the office that says the document never arrived. Against the keeper of the record, a person on their own is outmatched, and someone with expertise and no stake in the institution’s reputation is the only real counterweight.
Many of these organizations are nonprofits doing heroic work for people who could never pay. Legal aid lawyers, volunteer tax preparers, patient advocates in understaffed clinics: they’re what stands between a vulnerable person and an application left pending until the applicant gives up. Calling their existence a symptom doesn’t insult them. They’d mostly agree. Heroism is the interest a defective structure pays on its own negligence, and the people who do this work know better than anyone how much of it should never have been needed.
Routine and complex repair
When a repair service is needed for routine access or routine correction, that’s evidence of transferred burden. If an ordinary person with an ordinary claim needs a professional to receive a benefit they plainly qualify for, the institution has handed its own work to the market. If a wrong charge on a bill can only be reversed by someone who knows the coding manual, the institution has made its errors expensive to find and cheap to keep. Routine means the facts are not in dispute and the rule is clear, so the only obstacle is the process.
When a repair service is needed for complex disputes, it’s healthy. A contested diagnosis, an ambiguous statute, a claim that turns on how a rule should apply to facts no rule anticipated: these are real disagreements, and having someone skilled on your side is what a fair process looks like. Nobody thinks the existence of lawyers proves the courts are broken. What the lawyers spend their days on might.
The cases that get examined are mostly the routine kind. Much of what billing advocates find are plain errors. Credit disputes are often over entries that belong to someone else. Benefit applications fail for missing pages, and the page was frequently in the file. Fixing errors like these is repair in the literal sense: putting back what the institution broke, one customer at a time, while the machine that broke it keeps running. The appeal tests the clerk against the manual, and the repair economy is paid to win appeals while the manuals stay as they are.
When the burden moves back
If the burden moved back, hospitals would owe patients an accurate bill and pay a penalty when they sent a wrong one. Credit bureaus would bear the cost of proving an entry before it could harm anyone. Tax agencies would send people the return they already had the information to prepare. Benefit programs would enroll people automatically when the state already knew they qualified. Where provision is universal, the incentive to search for reasons to refuse weakens, and so does the demand for someone to fight the refusal.
The repair economy would shrink. It wouldn’t disappear, and its best parts would change shape. Advocates who spent their days on routine corrections would have time for hard cases, where their skill matters most. Organizations that learned an institution’s failure modes from thousands of individual fixes would hold exactly the knowledge a watchdog needs. The nonprofit that used to fix one patient’s bill at a time could publish which hospitals send the most wrong bills, and push for the rule that stops them. That’s a better use of the expertise than bailing water, and also the use the institutions least want, because a watchdog is paid to find patterns and a repair shop is paid to keep them private.
The for-profit parts of the repair economy would have a harder time, and they know it. The size of their interest, in lobbying dollars, is one more measure of how much burden the rest of us carry.
Watch where a repair economy spends its political money. If it lobbies for its clients’ problems to be solved, it’s an advocate. If it lobbies against the solution, it has become part of the institution it was supposed to be correcting, collecting a second toll on the same error.
Revision
31 October 2026: the claim that most of the repair economy is routine repair is now limited to the cases that get examined.
Notes
Bram Sable-Smith, “A Billing Expert Saved Big After Finding an Incorrect Charge in Her Husband’s ER Bill,” KFF Health News, October 25, 2022, kffhealthnews.org. The code was CPT 24505, closed treatment of a humerus fracture.
Sable-Smith, “A Billing Expert Saved Big.” The hospital’s letter acknowledging the coding was dated May 27, 2022.
Donna Rosato, “How to Get Help With Your Medical Bills,” Consumer Reports, August 1, 2018, consumerreports.org.
Social Security Administration, Annual Statistical Report on the Social Security Disability Insurance Program, 2024, section 4: roughly a fifth of disabled-worker applicants (18 to 21 percent of claims filed from 2014 through 2023) are awarded benefits at the initial level, and more are awarded on reconsideration and at hearings. Representatives’ fees under the fee-agreement process are capped at 25 percent of past-due benefits or $9,200, whichever is less (from November 2024).
Pamela Herd and Donald Moynihan, Administrative Burden: Policymaking by Other Means (Russell Sage Foundation, 2018).
Denmark introduced pre-populated returns in 1988 and Sweden in 1994; Norway, Estonia and others followed. OECD, Using Third Party Information Reports to Assist Taxpayers Meet Their Return Filing Obligations: Country Experiences with the Use of Pre-populated Personal Tax Returns (2006).
Justin Elliott and Lucas Waldron, “Here’s How TurboTax Just Tricked You Into Paying to File Your Taxes,” ProPublica, April 2019; Justin Elliott, “TurboTax Deliberately Hid Its Free File Page From Search Engines,” ProPublica, April 26, 2019; Justin Elliott and Paul Kiel, “Inside TurboTax’s 20-Year Fight to Stop Americans From Filing Their Taxes for Free,” ProPublica, October 17, 2019.
The IRS piloted Direct File in the 2024 filing season and extended it in 2025. The administration suspended it in November 2025, and it was unavailable for the 2026 season. OpenSecrets reported in April 2026 that Intuit and H&R Block set federal lobbying records in 2025, the year the program ended.