If this is you You're defending a senior center, bus route or bench at a budget hearing, and someone asks what it does for health.

Soup, Songs, and Sidewalks Are Healthcare

You are certified healthy by the absence of billing codes, and everything that kept you well before the first claim goes uncounted.

A case file: the rule, the person it landed on, and who could correct it.

The argument in 8 lines
If this is you
You're defending a senior center, bus route or bench at a budget hearing, and someone asks what it does for health.
The case
UC San Francisco researchers randomized twelve senior centers, and half started weekly choirs right away. After six months the 390 singers were less lonely and more interested in life.
The claim
Health is made in kitchens, on sidewalks and between neighbors, and the healthcare system ignores that care because nobody can bill for it.
The mechanism
Codes for social circumstances like living alone exist, but they aren't generally used for payment, so clinicians rarely record them, and what keeps people well has no code.
Who pays
People told to absorb structural neglect through personal resilience, who are then charged retail rates for crisis care when that resilience runs out.
Who can correct it
Medicare can change the form, and in October 2023 began paying hospitals more for homeless patients, but only once they're already in a hospital bed.
What would change it
Defend the public budget lines that pay for senior centers, library hours, bus routes and benches, in the budget hearings where they're decided.
The objection it answers
Valuing everyday care can sound like saying soup replaces chemotherapy. Acute medicine stays necessary as the last line of defense; trouble starts when it takes over the whole idea of health.
Reading settings

The question up top, the outline, the instrument and the what-next. Turn it off and you just get the essay.

A care room. A rope pulls tight between it and the person. Pieces of them are drawn off toward it.

You’ve lived alone for fifteen years, and your blood pressure has been up the whole time. You sing with the choir on Thursdays. Then the heart attack comes, and the hospital bills for the stent.

A person does not stay alive by visiting an examination room every six months. The biological and emotional maintenance that keeps a human nervous system from collapsing happens in kitchens, on sidewalks, across dinner tables, and through casual routines with people who expect nothing on an invoice.

Yet modern healthcare systems treat health as an industrial commodity delivered exclusively at the point of failure. You’re certified healthy by absence of billing codes. You enter the system only when some part of your body breaks down enough to generate a claim. Everything that happened before that moment (the loneliness that raised your cortisol, the poisoned air from the highway beside your apartment, the neighbor who dropped off a pot of lentils when you were too sick to stand) is classified as social background noise.

Call this the institutional capture of care: reducing life-sustaining maintenance to billable acute interventions.

The infrastructure of maintenance

Most care is preventative because it’s relational. When a neighbor brings soup to someone running a fever, the transaction produces more than calories. It provides biological surveillance without police powers, emotional buffering that calms autonomic arousal, and the immediate knowledge that they aren’t abandoned to die in a room.

A choir does the same work for loneliness. Researchers at UC San Francisco randomized twelve senior centers in the city: half started community choirs right away, and half waited six months. Each choir met weekly for 90 minutes with a professional director and music chosen for each center, and 65 percent of the 390 singers were people of color. After six months the singers were less lonely and more interested in life than the people still waiting. Their memory, balance and health care costs didn’t change.1 All twelve choirs were still singing when the results came out, and none of it is the kind of thing anyone bills for.

The same logic applies to physical geography. An urban neighborhood with shaded sidewalks, wide benches, community gardens, and accessible public transit works as a primary health intervention rather than an aesthetic achievement. It forces movement into daily routine, creates low-stakes chances for people to interact, and lowers the chronic baseline stress that accelerates cardiovascular decline. When cities replace public benches with anti-vagrancy spikes and design streets only for car traffic, they outsource joint damage, isolation, and respiratory illness to emergency departments six miles away instead of saving municipal budgets.

In nursing literature, Madeleine Leininger’s Transcultural Nursing Theory established decades ago that care can’t be detached from the cultural and relational fabric of the people receiving it. Imported clinical templates that treat the patient as an isolated biological specimen consistently fail because health is produced in context. Communal grief rituals, neighborhood cooking circles, and shared cultural practices are the baseline technology of human survival rather than folklore decorating clinical treatment.

The pathology of the billing code

The formal healthcare apparatus ignores these networks because capital can’t easily monetize what people give each other without an invoice.

A hospital system cannot bill Medicare for a front porch conversation that de-escalated a panic attack. An insurance conglomerate cannot take a margin on a neighborhood mutual-aid pantry. Industrial healthcare is paid when bodies have already disintegrated under chronic neglect, and pathology creates captive demand.

Billing does have a place for some of what comes before. Since the switch to ICD-10 in 2015, the diagnosis codes have included a block, Z55 through Z65, for social and economic circumstances: homelessness, problems related to living alone, the death of a family member. Clinicians rarely use it. In 2017 about 1.4 percent of the 33.7 million people in traditional Medicare had a claim carrying one of these codes, and living alone was recorded for 122,011 of them.2 By 2019 the share had reached 1.59 percent. When the agency listed the barriers to recording more, the first was that the codes aren’t generally used for payment, so nobody has a financial reason to write them down.3

In October 2023 Medicare began, for the first time, paying hospitals more for an inpatient coded as homeless.4 Even then, the claim counted the circumstance only at its worst and already in a hospital bed.

Run that forward for someone who stays well. No code exists for the neighbor’s lentils, the choir on Thursdays or the bench on the walk home. In the claims data that person is a blank until something breaks, and the things that kept her from breaking leave no record a budget can defend.

Under this model, institutions treat health as an individual moral responsibility: eat clean, download a meditation app, buy wearable trackers, and schedule your annual screening. If you collapse from chronic exhaustion, the system offers a prescription drug or a hospital bed. It will pay for the stent after your heart attack. It won’t pay anyone to write down that you’ve lived alone for fifteen years, let alone to repair the toxic working conditions or social isolation that kept your blood pressure up the whole time.

The system demands that people absorb structural neglect through personal resilience. Then it charges them retail rates for the crisis care they need when their resilience inevitably runs out.

Acute medicine is the last line, not the foundation

Recognizing inherent care doesn’t mean romanticizing poverty or suggesting that a warm bowl of soup replaces chemotherapy, surgical trauma bays, or insulin. Acute medical interventions need specialized technology and clinical training.

The point is that acute medicine is the last line of defense rather than the foundation. When acute medicine consumes the entire concept of health, communities lose the ability to organize their own maintenance. People are taught to see themselves as passive medical consumers waiting for expert rescue, rather than active participants in an ecology of mutual survival.

San Francisco’s trial choirs met in senior centers supported by the federal Administration on Aging, with the city’s aging department as a partner.1 What pays for places like that is a line in a public budget, not a claim, and the same goes for much of what keeps people well: the senior center, the library’s hours, the bus route, the bench. Those lines are decided in budget hearings where nobody bills anyone, and that’s where they can be defended.

Notes

1

Julene K. Johnson and colleagues, “A Community Choir Intervention to Promote Well-Being Among Diverse Older Adults: Results From the Community of Voices Trial,” Journals of Gerontology: Series B 75, no. 3 (2020): 549–559, a cluster-randomized trial. Session length, the choir directors, the city partners and the choirs’ continuation come from UCSF’s announcement of the results, November 2018. doi:10.1093/geronb/gby132; UCSF

2

CMS Office of Minority Health, “Z Codes Utilization among Medicare Fee-for-Service (FFS) Beneficiaries in 2017,” Data Highlight No. 18, January 2020: 467,136 beneficiaries had a Z code claim. Z codes were first available in 2016 Medicare claims. CMS

3

CMS OMH, “Utilization of Z Codes for Social Determinants of Health among Medicare Fee-for-Service Beneficiaries, 2019,” Data Highlight No. 24, September 2021, covering 33.1 million continuously enrolled beneficiaries. The other barriers it lists are the limited number of codes and clinicians’ uncertainty about what they can do. CMS

4

CMS, “New CMS Rule Promotes High-Quality Care and Rewards Hospitals that Deliver High-Quality Care to Underserved Populations,” press release, August 1, 2023, on the fiscal 2024 inpatient payment rule, effective October 1, 2023. Hospitals “will generally receive higher payments when a patient is experiencing homelessness” and the hospital reports the code. CMS

When they get you wrong or count on you

12
Who pays
People told to absorb structural neglect through personal resilience, who are then charged retail rates for crisis care when that resilience runs out.
Who can change it
Medicare can change the form, and in October 2023 began paying hospitals more for homeless patients, but only once they're already in a hospital bed.

Continue reading

What to read next

This essay belongs to the Infrastructural power pattern; its toolkit, topic and guide are one step away.

Related essays

New essays by email

One situation a week, the essays that explain it, and one question to put to the institution.

New essays by email

One situation a week, the essays that explain it, and one question to put to the institution.